Question 1

How can an organization implement an effective threat analysis and benefit from it?

Accepted Answer

An effective threat analysis is fundamental to a proactive cybersecurity strategy. It enables organizations to detect threats early and develop targeted countermeasures before damage occurs. A structured approach combines modern technologies with methodical procedures and continuous improvement.🔍 Methodical Approach:• Develop a clearly defined process with standardized methods for identifying, analyzing, and assessing threats, carried out in regular cycles• Consider both external threats (e.g., cybercriminals, state actors, hacktivists) and internal risks (e.g., insider threats, unintentional data leaks) in your analysis• Implement an asset management system that identifies, categorizes, and assesses the protection requirements of critical assets• Use established frameworks such as MITRE ATT&CK, STRIDE, or OWASP for structured capture and categorization of threats• Develop a company-specific threat model that accounts for your specific business processes, IT infrastructure, and protection requirements🌐 Threat Intelligence Integration:• Implement automated threat intelligence feeds from various sources to obtain current information on threats, vulnerabilities, and attack techniques• Aggregate and correlate data from multiple sources to create a comprehensive threat picture and reduce false positives• Use industry-specific intelligence sources that provide threat information tailored to your sector• Analyze threat information in the context of your organization to assess its relevance and potential impact• Establish processes for the timely distribution of relevant threat intelligence to the appropriate teams and decision-makers📊 Risk Assessment and Prioritization:• Develop a systematic methodology for assessing threats based on factors such as likelihood of occurrence, potential impact, and attack complexity• Prioritize identified threats based on their risk assessment and the criticality of the affected assets• Consider business factors such as regulatory requirements, reputational risks, and financial impacts in your risk assessment• Implement a dynamic risk model that can adapt to changing threat landscapes and business requirements• Conduct regular reassessments to ensure the currency of the risk assessment🛡️ Integration into Security Operations:• Link the results of threat analysis with your security monitoring systems for targeted detection of relevant threats• Use threat hunting techniques to proactively search for indicators of identified threats within your environment• Develop specific use cases for your SIEM system based on insights from threat analysis• Integrate threat analysis into your incident response processes for faster and more effective responses to security incidents• Establish a continuous feedback loop between security operations and threat analysis for ongoing improvement

Question 2

Which modern technologies and methods are advancing threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Threat analysis has undergone fundamental development in recent years through innovative technologies and methodological approaches. Modern solutions enable more precise, faster, and more comprehensive detection and assessment of threats than ever before.🤖 Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning:• Implement AI-based anomaly detection that learns normal user, system, and network behavior and can identify deviations that may indicate potential threats• Use deep learning algorithms to analyze large volumes of data and identify subtle correlations between various threat indicators• Apply Natural Language Processing (NLP) to evaluate unstructured data from threat intelligence feeds, security blogs, and social media• Implement self-learning systems that continuously improve their detection capabilities and adapt to new threat patterns• Use predictive analytics to forecast potential future threats based on historical data and current trends🔄 Automation and Orchestration:• Establish automated workflows for the collection, aggregation, and analysis of threat data from various sources• Implement SOAR platforms (Security Orchestration, Automation and Response) to integrate various security tools and automate response processes• Use API-based integrations between threat intelligence platforms and security controls for automatic implementation of countermeasures• Develop automated reporting mechanisms that present threat information in a format understandable to various stakeholders• Rely on continuous monitoring and automated alerts for timely detection of new or evolving threats📊 Visualization and Contextualization:• Implement advanced visualization tools that graphically represent complex threat scenarios and their impacts• Use techniques such as attack path mapping to visualize potential attack paths through your infrastructure and identify critical vulnerabilities• Use interactive dashboards that provide a comprehensive overview of the current threat landscape and enable deeper analysis• Establish context-based threat analyses that assess threat information in the context of your specific IT environment and business risks• Develop three-dimensional representations of the attack surface to better understand vulnerabilities and security gaps🌐 Collaborative Approaches:• Participate in threat intelligence sharing communities and ISACs (Information Sharing and Analysis Centers) in your industry to exchange threat information• Implement platforms for the structured exchange of Indicators of Compromise (IoCs) and threat intelligence with partners and trusted organizations• Use Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) techniques to collect and analyze publicly available information about potential threats• Establish cross-functional teams of experts from various areas (IT, security, business units) for comprehensive threat analysis• Promote collaboration between internal security teams and external security experts for a diverse perspective on the threat landscape

Question 3

How can organizations link their threat analysis to their overall security strategy?

Accepted Answer

A successful cybersecurity strategy requires the seamless integration of threat analysis into all relevant security processes and functions within the organization. Without this linkage, threat analysis remains an isolated tool with limited value.🔄 Strategic Alignment:• Develop a cyclical feedback loop between threat analysis and security strategy, where insights from threat analysis influence strategic direction and strategic priorities determine the focus of threat analysis• Align your threat analysis with organizational objectives and business risks to maximize relevance and business value• Implement a risk-based approach to your security strategy that is grounded in threat analysis insights and concentrates resources on the most relevant threats• Establish a continuous improvement process that provides for regular reviews and adjustments to the security strategy based on evolving threats• Integrate threat intelligence into your strategic roadmap for early planning of security measures against emerging threats🛠️ Operational Integration:• Use the results of threat analysis to configure and optimize security controls such as firewalls, intrusion detection/prevention systems, and endpoint security• Develop specific monitoring use cases for your SIEM system tailored to the identified threats• Establish threat hunting processes that actively search for indicators of specific threats identified in the threat analysis• Integrate threat analysis into your vulnerability management processes to prioritize vulnerabilities based on current threat information• Adapt your security awareness programs to specifically inform employees about current and relevant threats📊 Governance and Compliance:• Integrate threat analyses into your risk management frameworks to ensure consistent assessment and treatment of security risks• Use threat analysis to identify relevant compliance requirements and prioritize compliance measures• Implement structured management reporting that regularly informs about relevant threats and their potential impact on the organization• Integrate threat analyses into security assessments and audits for a comprehensive evaluation of your security posture• Establish a formal process for reporting threat analyses to executives and the board to ensure appropriate support and resource allocation🔄 Incident Response and Business Continuity:• Use threat analyses to develop and refine incident response playbooks for specific threat scenarios• Integrate current threat intelligence into your incident response processes to identify and address attacks more quickly and precisely• Conduct regular tabletop exercises and simulations based on current threat scenarios to test and improve response capabilities• Use insights from threat analysis for the development and updating of business continuity and disaster recovery plans• Establish a structured lessons-learned process following security incidents that feeds insights into future threat analysis

Question 4

How can organizations continuously improve their threat analysis capabilities?

Accepted Answer

Continuously improving threat analysis capabilities is critical for an effective cybersecurity strategy given the constantly evolving threat landscape. A systematic approach to developing these capabilities encompasses several dimensions.📊 Maturity Models and Assessments:• Implement a maturity model for your threat analysis capabilities that evaluates various dimensions such as processes, technology, expertise, and integration• Conduct regular self-assessments and external evaluations to determine the current maturity level and identify areas for improvement• Use established frameworks such as the Cyber Threat Intelligence Capability Maturity Model (CTI-CMM) or the Intelligence Cycle for structured assessment• Define clear objectives and milestones for the development of your threat analysis capabilities, based on assessment results• Create a multi-year roadmap for the systematic advancement of threat analysis capabilities, aligned with the organization's overall strategy👥 Team and Competency Development:• Invest in continuous training and development of your team through specialized courses, certifications, and conference participation on topics such as threat intelligence, malware analysis, and digital forensics• Promote the development of various specializations within your team to cover a broad spectrum of threats• Establish mentoring programs and internal knowledge-sharing formats to share experience and expertise within the team• Use external resources such as consulting services, managed security services, or specialized threat intelligence providers to supplement internal capabilities• Foster a culture of continuous learning and curiosity that is essential for threat analysis🔍 Process Optimization:• Implement a continuous improvement process with regular reviews and adjustments to threat analysis processes• Conduct systematic post-incident analyses following security incidents to evaluate whether relevant threats were identified in advance and what improvements are necessary• Standardize and document your threat analysis processes to ensure consistency and efficiently onboard new team members• Establish clear metrics to measure the effectiveness of your threat analysis, such as detection rates, false positive rates, and time-to-detection• Automate manual and repetitive tasks to free up resources for more complex analyses🔄 Feedback Loops and Integration:• Establish structured feedback mechanisms between users of threat analysis (e.g., SOC teams, incident response teams) and analysts• Regularly measure the relevance and value of the threat information provided to various stakeholders• Continuously refine the integration between threat analysis and operational security functions such as monitoring, vulnerability management, and incident response• Develop tailored reporting formats for different audiences, from technical teams to management• Implement mechanisms for validating and ensuring the quality of your threat analyses

Question 5

What role does threat intelligence play in threat analysis and how can it be used effectively?

Accepted Answer

Threat intelligence forms the foundation of effective threat analysis by providing current, relevant, and context-specific information about potential attackers, their methods, and objectives. Targeted integration of threat intelligence into the security strategy enables a proactive protection approach.📊 Types and Sources of Threat Intelligence:• Use tactical intelligence (e.g., IOCs, malware signatures) for the immediate detection of known threats by integrating it into security controls such as firewalls, EDR, or SIEM systems• Integrate operational intelligence (e.g., information on TTPs — Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures) for a deeper understanding of attacker methods and to develop effective detection and defense strategies• Consider strategic intelligence (e.g., threat trends, attacker motivations) for long-term security planning and resource allocation• Combine various intelligence sources such as commercial feeds, open source intelligence, information sharing communities, and your own internal findings• Establish a structured process for the continuous evaluation and selection of relevant intelligence sources based on factors such as quality, currency, and relevance to your organization🔍 Intelligence Processing and Analysis:• Implement a systematic intelligence cycle consisting of planning, collection, processing, analysis, dissemination, and feedback• Use Threat Intelligence Platforms (TIPs) for the aggregation, deduplication, enrichment, and correlation of intelligence from various sources• Enrich external intelligence with internal contextual information to increase its relevance to your specific environment• Analyze threat data using various methods such as cluster analysis, time series analysis, or behavioral analysis to identify patterns and correlations• Develop a systematic methodology for prioritizing intelligence based on relevance, criticality, and currency🌐 Operationalization of Threat Intelligence:• Integrate threat intelligence into your SIEM system for automated detection of known threat indicators and correlation with internal events• Use intelligence-based detection rules and signatures for your security controls such as IDS/IPS, EDR, and firewalls• Implement automated workflows for the timely distribution of relevant intelligence to the appropriate systems and teams• Develop intelligence-based hunting hypotheses for proactive threat hunting in your environment• Use threat intelligence to enrich security incidents with contextual information for faster and more effective incident response📱 People and Process:• Establish dedicated roles and responsibilities for the processing, analysis, and distribution of threat intelligence• Develop intelligence requirements that reflect the information needs of various stakeholders and teams• Implement regular threat briefings and intelligence updates for various audiences, from SOC analysts to the CISO• Create feedback mechanisms to continuously improve the usefulness and quality of the intelligence provided• Promote the development of intelligence skills within your security team through specialized training and certifications

Question 6

How can organizations use threat analyses to develop targeted prevention strategies?

Accepted Answer

Translating threat analyses into effective prevention strategies is critical to maximizing the value of your security investments. Systematic implementation of the insights gained enables targeted and efficient protective measures.🛡️ Strategic Planning:• Develop a defensive matrix that links identified threats with corresponding defense strategies and security controls• Implement a risk-based approach that prioritizes security measures based on risk assessment and business relevance• Create a multi-tiered protection plan with short-term quick wins, medium-term improvements, and long-term strategic measures• Use frameworks such as the NIST Cybersecurity Framework or ISO 27001 as a reference to ensure your prevention strategies cover all relevant areas• Define clear protection objective priorities (e.g., availability vs. confidentiality) based on specific threats and business requirements🔒 Technical Implementation:• Implement defense-in-depth architectures with multiple layers of protection specifically aligned to the identified threat vectors• Develop tailored security control sets for various applications and systems based on their specific threat exposure• Use threat-informed defense through targeted configuration of security tools based on the TTPs (Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures) of relevant attackers• Implement zero trust architectures with continuous verification and minimal access rights in response to modern threat scenarios• Rely on adaptive security architectures that can dynamically adjust to evolving threats📊 Monitoring and Validation:• Develop specific monitoring strategies and use cases for your SIEM system based on threat analysis• Use purple team exercises in which red teams attempt to exploit specific attack paths identified in the threat analysis while blue teams defend against them• Conduct regular penetration tests specifically targeting the attack vectors identified in the threat analysis• Implement Breach and Attack Simulation (BAS) tools for continuous validation of the effectiveness of your implemented security controls• Establish a metrics program that measures the effectiveness of your prevention strategies using clearly defined KPIs👥 Organizational Measures:• Develop targeted security awareness programs aligned to the specific threats and attack vectors relevant to your organization• Establish clear incident response processes and playbooks for the most likely attack scenarios identified in the threat analysis• Implement specific security policies and standards aimed at mitigating the identified threats• Promote an organization-wide security culture that sharpens awareness of the specific threats facing your organization• Strengthen collaboration between security, IT, and business units for effective implementation of security measures across all areas of the organization

Question 7

What role do Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) play in the modern threat landscape?

Accepted Answer

Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) represent a particularly sophisticated form of cyberattack carried out by highly skilled attackers with substantial resources. Understanding them is indispensable for comprehensive threat analysis in today's cybersecurity landscape.🔍 Characteristics and Evolution:• Recognize the defining characteristics of APTs: targeted attacks, long-term campaigns, advanced techniques, extensive resources, and strategic objectives such as espionage, sabotage, or long-term compromise• Understand the evolution of APTs from early state-directed campaigns to diversified actors, including cybercriminals employing APT-like techniques for financial gain• Consider the increasing availability of APT tools on the dark web, which is leading to a "democratization" of advanced attack techniques• Analyze evolving tactics such as supply chain attacks, living-off-the-land techniques, and the exploitation of legitimate tools for malicious purposes• Observe the increasing specialization and division of labor within APT groups, leading to highly professional operations👤 Actors and Motivations:• Identify various APT actors and their specific motivations, from state-sponsored groups (espionage, sabotage) to financially motivated cybercriminals• Analyze industry-specific targeting patterns to identify the threat actors most relevant to your organization• Understand the geopolitical factors that influence APT activity and how these may affect your threat landscape• Consider the varying capabilities and resources of different APT groups in your risk assessment• Observe changes in target selection and tactics in response to geopolitical developments or new business opportunities🔄 Attack Methodology and Tactics:• Analyze the typical APT attack cycle from initial compromise through privilege escalation, lateral movement, and data exfiltration to long-term persistence• Understand modern initial access vectors such as spear phishing, supply chain compromise, or exploitation of vulnerabilities in external systems• Identify evasion techniques such as fileless malware, legacy protocol abuse, and anti-forensic methods that APTs use to circumvent security measures• Consider command-and-control infrastructures and their evolution toward hard-to-detect communication methods such as domain fronting or encrypted channels• Understand the significance of living-off-the-land techniques, in which legitimate system processes and tools are abused for malicious purposes🛡️ Defense Strategies:• Implement a defense-in-depth strategy with multiple layers of protection specifically aligned to the tactics of relevant APT groups• Establish continuous security monitoring with a focus on anomaly detection and subtle indicators of compromise• Develop specific detection strategies for the tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) of relevant APT actors• Deploy proactive threat hunting to identify undetected compromises or signs of APT activity• Implement zero trust architectures and microsegmentation to impede lateral movement and limit damage in the event of a compromise

Question 8

How can organizations effectively integrate threat hunting into their threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Threat hunting is a proactive cybersecurity discipline that goes beyond traditional detection methods by actively searching for previously undetected threats within the IT environment. Effective integration into threat analysis significantly improves detection capabilities.🎯 Strategic Foundations:• Establish a structured, hypothesis-based approach to threat hunting that builds on the insights from your threat analysis• Develop specific hunting hypotheses based on current threat intelligence, industry-specific threats, and known TTPs (Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures) of relevant attackers• Prioritize hunting activities based on identified risks and the criticality of assets and systems• Integrate threat hunting as a continuous process into your security operations cycle, not as a one-time or sporadic activity• Develop a program with various hunting levels, from basic, regular search activities to in-depth, specialized hunts for advanced threats🔍 Methodical Approach:• Implement various hunting methods such as IOC sweeping (searching for known indicators), TTP hunting (searching for suspicious behavioral patterns), and anomaly hunting (detecting unusual activities)• Use frameworks such as MITRE ATT&CK to structure your hunting activities and ensure comprehensive coverage of various attack techniques• Develop a hunting maturity model roadmap for the systematic advancement of your hunting capabilities, from simple ad hoc searches to advanced, data-driven hunting processes• Implement an iterative hunting process consisting of hypothesis formation, data collection, investigation, verification, and documentation of results• Establish a continuous feedback loop in which hunting insights feed back into threat analysis and generate new hunting hypotheses⚙️ Technological Enablers:• Implement advanced logging and telemetry systems that collect detailed data for hunting activities from various sources (network traffic, endpoint activities, cloud logs)• Use SIEM and XDR platforms as central hubs for threat hunting with capabilities for correlation, visualization, and analysis of large data volumes• Deploy specialized hunting tools that can visualize process flows, network communications, and system changes• Implement data lake architectures for long-term storage and flexible analysis of large data volumes• Use automation and playbooks for recurring hunting tasks to increase efficiency and free up resources for more complex investigations👥 Team and Capabilities:• Build a specialized hunting team combining technical skills (data analysis, forensics, malware analysis) with contextual knowledge (network architecture, business processes)• Invest in continuous development of your hunting team in areas such as attack techniques, forensics, data analysis, and emerging threats• Foster an analytical mindset and creativity that are essential for successful threat hunting• Establish close collaboration between threat hunters, SOC analysts, incident responders, and threat intelligence analysts• Create a culture that promotes curiosity, continuous learning, and the sharing of insights

Question 9

How can an organization systematically analyze and reduce its attack surface?

Accepted Answer

The systematic analysis and reduction of the attack surface is a fundamental component of effective threat analysis and cybersecurity strategy. A comprehensive approach combines technical measures with organizational processes and continuous monitoring.🔍 Attack Surface Mapping and Inventory:• Implement a continuous asset discovery process that automatically captures all systems, applications, network components, and cloud resources and documents them in a central CMDB (Configuration Management Database)• Create a comprehensive network topology that visualizes connections, data flows, and trust relationships between various systems and network segments• Conduct regular external attack surface scans to identify exposed services, open ports, unprotected resources, and unpatched internet-facing systems• Implement shadow IT discovery processes to identify unauthorized or unmanaged IT resources, which are often particularly vulnerable• Create a risk map of your attack surface that visualizes the criticality of various assets, their vulnerabilities, and potential attack paths🛡️ Fundamental Reduction Strategies:• Implement the principle of least privilege for user accounts, applications, and systems to limit the impact of a compromise• Segment your network environment based on security requirements and data classification to impede lateral movement by attackers• Reduce the number of open ports, services, and applications to the operationally necessary minimum, especially for internet-facing systems• Implement automated patch management processes for the timely remediation of known security vulnerabilities in operating systems and applications• Conduct regular clean-ups to remove unused accounts, outdated systems, and no-longer-needed applications🔄 Advanced Methods:• Use attack path analysis tools that model potential attack paths through your infrastructure and identify critical choke points• Implement microsegmentation of your network environment with granular access controls based on zero trust principles• Use virtual patching through WAFs or IPS systems to protect vulnerabilities that cannot be patched immediately• Implement API security measures such as API gateways, rate limiting, and content validation for your application interfaces• Conduct continuous security testing such as penetration tests and red team exercises to identify new vulnerabilities and attack vectors📊 Continuous Monitoring and Management:• Implement an Attack Surface Management (ASM) program with continuous monitoring, assessment, and improvement• Establish KPIs for your attack surface, such as number of exposed services, average time-to-patch, or proportion of critical systems with current security updates• Conduct regular risk assessments that account for new threats, changing business requirements, and technological developments• Integrate attack surface management into your change management processes to ensure that new systems or applications do not unnecessarily expand your attack surface• Use threat intelligence to focus your monitoring activities on known actively exploited vulnerabilities or specific attack vectors

Question 10

How can threat analysis be integrated into DevSecOps processes?

Accepted Answer

Integrating threat analysis into DevSecOps processes is critical for a proactive security strategy in modern development environments. By incorporating security considerations early, organizations can reduce risks while maintaining development velocity.🔄 Shift-Left Approach:• Implement threat modeling as an integral part of the planning and design phase of new applications or features, before the first line of code is written• Use automated tools for Static Application Security Testing (SAST) in your CI/CD pipeline to identify security issues early in the code• Integrate vulnerability scanning into your build processes to detect known vulnerabilities in dependencies and components used• Develop security user stories and abuse cases as part of your agile development methodology to define security requirements early• Establish security champions in development teams who act as a bridge between security and development and bring threat intelligence into the development process🛠️ Pipeline Integration:• Implement automated security tests in your CI/CD pipeline that run on every commit or build and provide real-time feedback• Combine various testing methods such as SAST, DAST (Dynamic Application Security Testing), SCA (Software Composition Analysis), and container scanning for comprehensive coverage• Define security gates with clear pass/fail criteria that ensure certain security standards are met before deployment to production environments• Integrate automated compliance checks that validate regulatory requirements and internal security policies• Use Infrastructure as Code (IaC) scanning to detect security issues in your infrastructure configuration early🔍 Continuous Threat Analysis:• Implement Runtime Application Self-Protection (RASP) and Web Application Firewalls (WAF) configured based on current threat intelligence• Establish continuous security monitoring across all environments (development, test, production) with a focus on new and evolving threats• Conduct regular automated security tests such as penetration tests or fuzzing based on current threat scenarios• Use feedback from security monitoring of production applications to refine security measures in development• Implement a closed feedback loop in which insights from security incidents feed back into the development and design phase👥 Culture and Processes:• Foster a collaborative security culture in which developers, operations, and security teams work together to improve security• Invest in continuous training and awareness programs on current threats and secure software development for all stakeholders• Establish shared accountability for security across the entire software development lifecycle• Implement agile security processes that can respond quickly to new threats without disrupting the development flow• Use post-incident reviews and lessons learned as learning opportunities for all teams and for continuous improvement of security measures

Question 11

How do threat analyses differ for on-premises, cloud, and hybrid environments?

Accepted Answer

Conducting effective threat analyses requires a deep understanding of the specific characteristics of different IT environments. On-premises, cloud, and hybrid architectures each bring their own challenges and threat models.🏢 On-Premises Environments:• Focus on physical security aspects such as access controls to server rooms, network infrastructure, and terminal devices, which are typically delegated to the provider in cloud scenarios• Consider the particular importance of perimeter security, as clear network boundaries with defined entry and exit points exist• Analyze risks associated with legacy systems and applications, which are more commonly found in on-premises environments and often present particular vulnerabilities• Assess internal threats such as privileged administrators with direct physical access to systems and infrastructure• Consider challenges with patch management and updates that can arise in isolated or complex on-premises environments☁️ Cloud Environments:• Implement the shared responsibility model as the basis of your threat analysis, with a clear distinction between provider and customer responsibilities• Analyze cloud-specific threat vectors such as misconfigured storage buckets, unsecured APIs, insecure access controls, and identity management risks• Consider particular challenges in monitoring and detection across distributed cloud resources, especially in multi-cloud strategies• Focus on containment strategies, as traditional network segmentation must be implemented differently in cloud environments• Assess risks from automation and infrastructure-as-code, which can lead to rapidly scalable security issues when misconfigurations are present🔄 Hybrid Environments:• Identify complex dependencies and integration points between on-premises and cloud components as potential attack vectors• Analyze security risks at the transition points between different environments, particularly during data transfers and authentication processes• Assess challenges in achieving consistent security monitoring across different environments that may require different tools and approaches• Consider complexity risks arising from different security control mechanisms, management tools, and authorization models• Identify shadow IT and uncontrolled cloud usage as particular risks in hybrid environments🛠️ Methodological Differences:• Adapt your threat modeling methods to the respective environment: traditional methods such as STRIDE or PASTA for on-premises, cloud-specific frameworks for cloud resources• Implement different scanning and assessment strategies: network-based scans for on-premises, API-based assessments for cloud resources• Develop specific monitoring strategies: agent-based monitoring for on-premises systems, API- and log-based monitoring for cloud services• Use different tools for different environments: traditional vulnerability scanners for on-premises, Cloud Security Posture Management (CSPM) for cloud resources• Implement adapted incident response processes that account for the specific characteristics and constraints of each environment

Question 12

What role do cyber threat frameworks play in threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Cyber threat frameworks provide structured approaches for categorizing, analyzing, and communicating cyber threats. They establish a common vocabulary and reference model for various stakeholders and enable a systematic approach to threat analysis.📋 MITRE ATT&CK Framework:• Use the ATT&CK Framework as a comprehensive knowledge base for known attack tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) of various threat actors• Implement ATT&CK as the basis for your threat intelligence activities by mapping observed threats to the corresponding techniques in the framework• Develop a detection coverage map that compares your detection capabilities against the various ATT&CK techniques and identifies gaps• Use the framework for red team exercises and purple team activities to simulate realistic attack scenarios and test defensive measures• Use ATT&CK to prioritize security measures based on the frequency and relevance of specific attack techniques for your organization🔄 Cyber Kill Chain:• Use the Cyber Kill Chain as a conceptual model to understand the various phases of a cyberattack and develop corresponding defense strategies• Implement defense-in-depth strategies aligned to each phase of the kill chain, from reconnaissance through command & control to actions on objectives• Develop specific detection and prevention measures for each phase of the kill chain to interrupt attacks at an early stage• Use the model for the analysis of security incidents to understand at which phase an attack was detected and where there is potential for improvement• Communicate threats and security measures to non-technical stakeholders using the easily understandable kill chain model🛡️ NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF):• Use the NIST CSF as a comprehensive framework for structuring all your cybersecurity activities along the functions Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond, and Recover• Integrate your threat analysis particularly into the Identify function for systematic capture of assets, business requirements, and risks• Use the various framework categories to ensure that your threat analysis covers all relevant aspects and is aligned with other security activities• Implement the framework for maturity assessments and to identify areas for improvement in your threat analysis processes• Use the NIST CSF for communication with executives and for governance-related aspects of your threat analysis📊 Diamond Model of Intrusion Analysis:• Use the Diamond Model for comprehensive analysis of intrusion events by examining the four elements: adversary, infrastructure, capabilities, and victim, as well as their relationships• Use the model to contextualize threat intelligence and identify connections between different attack campaigns• Implement the Diamond Model for attribution analyses that help you attribute attacks to specific threat actors• Develop pivot strategies based on the model to draw conclusions from known elements of an attack to unknown ones• Use the model to assess the quality and completeness of your threat information

Question 13

How can organizations integrate IoT- and OT-specific threats into their threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

The integration of IoT (Internet of Things) and OT (Operational Technology) into enterprise environments creates new attack vectors and security challenges. A comprehensive threat analysis must account for these specific technologies and their unique risk profiles.🔍 Understanding the Specific Threat Landscape:• Analyze the particular types of threats for IoT/OT environments such as manipulation of sensor data, physical sabotage, denial-of-service attacks, or takeover of devices to create botnets• Consider the potentially far-reaching consequences of attacks on OT systems that control physical processes and, if compromised, can pose risks to human life, the environment, or critical infrastructure• Identify industry-specific threats for your IoT/OT environments, e.g., in manufacturing, energy, healthcare, or smart buildings• Understand the increasing convergence of IT and OT and the resulting security implications, particularly the exposure of traditionally isolated OT systems to IT-based attacks• Consider the expanded attack potential arising from the massive increase in devices and connections in IoT/OT networks📋 Asset Inventory and Risk Classification:• Implement specialized discovery methods for IoT/OT devices that use passive scanning techniques and protocol-specific identification to avoid disrupting sensitive operational environments• Create a comprehensive inventory of all IoT/OT devices with detailed information on device type, firmware version, communication protocols, connectivity, and criticality• Categorize IoT/OT assets based on their criticality to business processes, potential security impact, and accessibility to attackers• Analyze communication patterns and data flows between IoT/OT devices as well as between OT and IT networks• Document legacy systems and devices that no longer receive updates but remain operationally necessary🛡️ Specific Protection Strategies:• Implement comprehensive network segmentation with multiple security zones and strictly controlled transition points in accordance with the Purdue Enterprise Reference Architecture model for industrial control systems• Establish specific security monitoring solutions for OT networks that detect protocol anomalies and minimize operational impact• Implement secure remote access solutions for IoT/OT devices with strong authentication and detailed logging• Develop OT-specific patch management strategies that account for operational availability requirements and maintenance windows• Apply security-by-design principles when integrating new IoT/OT devices, including the assessment of security features prior to procurement🔄 Continuous Assessment and Response:• Conduct specific IoT/OT security assessments that identify vulnerabilities in firmware, communication protocols, and physical protection mechanisms• Develop specific incident response plans for OT security incidents that prioritize operational continuity and safety• Implement continuous monitoring of the IoT/OT environment with specialized tools capable of detecting anomalous behavior in industrial control systems• Conduct regular tabletop exercises and simulations covering IoT/OT-specific attack scenarios• Establish a continuous process for integrating new IoT/OT threat information into your security strategy

Question 14

How can simulations and exercises improve threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Simulations and exercises are indispensable tools for validating, improving, and operationalizing threat analyses. They enable organizations to test theoretical threat models in practice, identify vulnerabilities, and improve response capabilities.🎮 Red Team Exercises:• Conduct advanced red team operations that specifically test attack vectors and techniques identified in your threat analysis• Integrate current threat intelligence into your red team exercises to simulate realistic attack methods of relevant threat actors• Combine technical attacks with social engineering elements for comprehensive security assessments that consider both technical and human factors• Develop long-term, covert red team campaigns that simulate Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) and test your organization's detection capabilities over extended periods• Conduct targeted exercises specifically aimed at validating particular hypotheses or assumptions from your threat analysis🛡️ Purple Team Approaches:• Implement structured purple team exercises in which red teams and blue teams collaborate to conduct attacks, improve detection, and enhance defensive measures• Use frameworks such as MITRE ATT&CK as a common reference for the planning, execution, and evaluation of purple team exercises• Conduct regular purple team sessions focused on specific tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) identified as relevant in your threat analysis• Develop a structured process for documenting and integrating insights from purple team exercises into your security controls and monitoring systems• Use automated tools to simulate attack scenarios, enabling regular and consistent testing📋 Tabletop Exercises:• Conduct regular tabletop exercises with various stakeholders to test and improve the organizational response to complex threat scenarios• Develop realistic scenarios based on your threat analysis that account for specific attack vectors, threat actors, and potential impacts on your critical business processes• Integrate business continuity and disaster recovery aspects into your exercises to create a comprehensive understanding of the impact of security incidents• Involve executives in executive tabletops to test strategic decision-making processes and crisis management capabilities• Document lessons learned and develop concrete action plans to address identified vulnerabilities and areas for improvement🧪 Breach and Attack Simulation (BAS):• Implement BAS tools that continuously and automatically test various attack techniques against your security controls• Configure your BAS platform based on the relevant threats and attack vectors identified in your threat analysis• Conduct regular simulations to validate the effectiveness of your security controls against new threats and attack techniques• Use the results for continuous improvement of your security architecture and to prioritize investments in security controls• Integrate BAS into your security validation processes to obtain continuous feedback on the effectiveness of your security measures

Question 15

How can organizations integrate social engineering risks into their threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Social engineering represents one of the most effective and frequently used attack methods. A comprehensive threat analysis must account for these human-centric attack vectors and develop appropriate defense strategies.👥 Typologies and Vectors:• Identify the various forms of social engineering attacks relevant to your organization: phishing, spear phishing, whaling, vishing (voice phishing), smishing (SMS phishing), pretexting, baiting, and physical social engineering methods• Analyze industry-specific social engineering trends and tactics that are specifically targeted at organizations in your sector• Assess social engineering as an initial access vector for more complex attack campaigns such as ransomware, data theft, or espionage• Consider the increasing sophistication of social engineering attacks through the use of AI-generated content, deep fakes, and tailored attack scenarios• Understand the psychological principles that make social engineering attacks successful: authority, scarcity, reciprocity, social proof, liking, and urgency🎯 Risk Assessment and Modeling:• Develop a social engineering risk assessment framework that considers various factors: visibility and public presence of employees, access permissions, publicly available information about your organization and its employees• Identify high-risk roles and individuals in your organization who, due to their access rights, public visibility, or decision-making authority, represent particularly attractive targets for social engineering attacks• Conduct Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) analyses to understand what information about your organization and employees is publicly available and could be used for social engineering attacks• Assess social engineering risks in the context of your overall security architecture, particularly with regard to multi-factor authentication, access controls, and network segmentation• Integrate social engineering scenarios into your threat modeling processes, especially for critical business processes and applications🛡️ Prevention and Detection Strategies:• Implement a comprehensive security awareness program with regular, audience-specific training on current social engineering techniques• Conduct realistic phishing simulations based on current techniques identified in your threat analysis• Develop clear processes for employees to report suspicious activities or contact attempts• Implement technical controls such as email filtering solutions, anti-phishing tools, URL filtering, and sandboxing for email attachments• Establish strict verification processes for sensitive actions such as financial transactions, data access, or password changes📊 Measurement and Continuous Improvement:• Develop metrics to assess the effectiveness of your social engineering defenses, such as phishing simulation results, reporting rates for suspicious emails, or incidents• Implement a continuous feedback system that integrates insights from successful and attempted social engineering attacks into your defense strategies• Conduct regular assessments of the effectiveness of your security awareness programs and adapt them based on results and new threats• Analyze trends and patterns in social engineering attempts against your organization to better predict and defend against future attacks• Use benchmarking and external best practices to continuously improve your social engineering defense strategies

Question 16

How does the GDPR affect the conduct of threat analyses?

Accepted Answer

The GDPR imposes specific requirements on the handling of personal data that must also be considered when conducting threat analyses. A data protection-compliant approach integrates privacy aspects into the threat analysis process from the outset.

📋 Legal Framework:

• Consider GDPR requirements in your threat analysis as part of compliance risk and as an asset to be protected in terms of the confidentiality of personal data

• Integrate data protection-by-design principles into your threat analysis processes, particularly when assessing risks to the rights and freedoms of data subjects

• Understand the GDPR requirements on the security of processing (Art. 32) as a minimum standard for your security measures

• Account for specific GDPR provisions such as reporting obligations in the event of personal data breaches (Art. 33, 34) in your incident response plans

• Integrate insights from Data Protection Impact Assessments (DPIAs) into your threat analysis, particularly when identifying assets requiring protection and potential impacts

🔍 Data Collection and Analysis:

• When collecting threat intelligence, implement procedures to minimize personal data, e.g., through pseudonymization or anonymization where possible

• Establish clear guidelines for handling personal data during security assessments, penetration tests, and red team exercises

• Document the purpose of data processing for all threat analysis activities and ensure that only the data required for that purpose is processed

• Develop processes for the secure handling of logs and other data sources that may contain personal data, particularly during forensic investigations

• Establish appropriate retention periods for security-relevant data that are compatible with the purpose of threat analysis

🔐 Data Protection-Compliant Security Measures:

• Integrate into your threat analysis the assessment of risks specifically for personal data, including those with particularly high protection requirements (Art.

9 GDPR)

• Develop security measures based on your threat analysis that are proportionate to the risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons

• Implement methods for the regular review, assessment, and evaluation of the effectiveness of your technical and organizational measures

• When selecting security controls, pay particular attention to measures for the pseudonymization and encryption of personal data

• Establish processes for restoring the availability of personal data following physical or technical incidents

👥 Collaboration with Data Protection Officers:

• Involve your Data Protection Officer (DPO) early in your threat analysis processes, particularly when identifying and assessing risks to personal data

• Establish regular coordination between security and data protection teams to harmonize threat analyses and Data Protection Impact Assessments

• Use the expertise of your DPO in developing security measures that are both effective and data protection-compliant

• Ensure that your DPO is promptly informed of security-relevant incidents that may affect personal data

• Involve your DPO in the prioritization of security measures to ensure that data protection aspects are adequately considered

Question 17

How can artificial intelligence be used to improve threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are fundamentally changing the way organizations analyze, detect, and defend against threats. These technologies enable scalable, fast, and precise analysis of large data volumes and help identify complex threat patterns.🔍 Anomaly Detection and Behavioral Analysis:• Implement AI-based behavioral analysis systems that learn from normal user, system, and network behavior and can detect deviations that may indicate potential threats• Use unsupervised learning algorithms to detect novel and previously unknown threats (zero-day attacks) that may be missed by signature-based systems• Apply deep learning models to detect subtle anomalies in complex data streams, such as network traffic, API calls, or user activities• Implement User and Entity Behavior Analytics (UEBA) that analyze the behavior of users and entities over time and identify high-risk activities• Use time series anomaly detection to identify unusual activity patterns that may indicate threats such as slow, targeted attacks📊 Pattern Recognition and Correlation:• Apply machine learning algorithms to identify complex patterns and correlations in large security data volumes that would be difficult for human analysts to detect• Implement clustering algorithms to identify connections between seemingly unrelated security events and uncover coordinated attack campaigns• Use graph analysis techniques to visualize and investigate complex relationships between entities, events, and threat indicators• Implement automatic clustering of threat indicators to identify attack campaigns and group related threats• Apply Natural Language Processing (NLP) to analyze unstructured threat intelligence data from various sources such as security blogs, forums, or social media🛡️ Prediction and Proactive Defense:• Use predictive analytics to forecast potential future attack targets and methods based on historical data and current trends• Implement AI-supported vulnerability management systems that prioritize vulnerabilities based on current threat intelligence and your specific environment• Apply decision support systems that assist security analysts in decision-making in complex threat scenarios• Use reinforcement learning models that continuously learn from feedback and improve their detection and defense strategies• Implement adaptive security controls that automatically adjust to changing threat landscapes based on ML insights🔄 Automation and Orchestration:• Deploy AI-supported Security Orchestration, Automation and Response (SOAR) platforms that automate routine tasks and orchestrate complex incident response workflows• Use automation for rapid triage and contextualization of security alerts to increase the efficiency of your SOC• Implement self-learning systems that learn from past incident response actions and suggest optimal responses to new incidents• Use natural language generation for the automatic creation of threat reports and summaries for various stakeholders• Apply AI-supported tools that automate and optimize the entire threat intelligence lifecycle from collection through analysis to distribution

Question 18

How can organizations link their threat analysis to business impact?

Accepted Answer

An effective threat analysis must be closely linked to the business context in order to deliver truly valuable insights. Translating technical risks into business impacts is critical for informed decisions and the prioritization of security measures.💼 Identification of Critical Business Processes:• Conduct Business Impact Analyses (BIA) to identify, assess, and document critical business processes, their dependencies, and recovery objectives• Create a hierarchy of business functions and processes with clear dependencies and criticality ratings to better understand the impact of security incidents• Quantify the financial and operational impacts of process disruptions through metrics such as revenue impact, productivity loss, or recovery costs• Identify critical time windows and business cycles in which certain systems or processes are particularly critical (e.g., quarter-end, tax periods, seasonal peaks)• Consider not only direct operational impacts but also indirect consequences such as reputational damage, regulatory consequences, or loss of market share🔗 Linking Assets and Business Processes:• Create a comprehensive mapping matrix that links IT assets and systems to the business processes they support and assesses their criticality for each process• Analyze data flows between various systems and their significance for business processes to identify dependencies and potential single points of failure• Implement continuous asset management that automatically updates relationships when changes are made to IT systems or business processes• Conduct regular workshops with business and IT stakeholders to improve shared understanding of critical systems and their business significance• Develop a service dependency map that shows how various IT services interact with each other and which business processes they support📊 Risk Quantification and Assessment:• Implement frameworks such as FAIR (Factor Analysis of Information Risk) for the quantitative assessment of cyber risks in financial terms• Develop Business Risk Indicators (BRIs) that directly link security risks to specific business impacts• Calculate the expected Annual Loss Expectancy (ALE) for various threat scenarios by multiplying the likelihood of occurrence by the estimated impact• Use Monte Carlo simulations to model complex risk scenarios and their potential business impacts under conditions of uncertainty• Develop a risk register that documents both technical threats and their business impacts in language understandable to all stakeholders🧩 Integration into Decision-Making Processes:• Develop risk dashboards for executives that present security risks in business-relevant terms and visualize trends over time• Integrate cybersecurity risks into the Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) of your organization to enable a comprehensive risk assessment• Implement a risk-based approach for investment decisions in cybersecurity that prioritizes security measures based on their ability to reduce business risks• Conduct regular risk review meetings with business stakeholders to develop a shared understanding of the current threat landscape and its business relevance• Establish clear communication channels between security, IT, and business units for effective collaboration in risk assessment and mitigation

Question 19

What role does threat intelligence sharing play in threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

Threat intelligence sharing is a powerful tool for improving threat analysis. By exchanging threat information, organizations can benefit from the insights and experiences of others and thereby strengthen their own defense capabilities.🌐 Ecosystem and Communities:• Participate in industry-specific Information Sharing and Analysis Centers (ISACs) or Information Sharing and Analysis Organizations (ISAOs) that share threat information tailored to your sector• Join regional or national threat sharing initiatives, which often also incorporate information from government agencies and law enforcement authorities• Build trusted relationships with peer organizations in your industry for direct, bilateral exchange of threat information and best practices• Use open source threat intelligence communities and platforms that collect and share freely accessible threat information• Consider participating in threat intelligence programs offered by security vendors that aggregate information from their customers and return enriched intelligence📋 Types of Shared Information:• Share and use tactical indicators such as IPs, domains, hashes, and URLs that can be used to detect known threats in your environment• Exchange information on Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTPs) that provide deeper insights into attack methods and are more valuable in the long term than individual indicators• Provide and receive context on threats, such as information about attacker groups, their motives, targets, and typical methods of operation• Share experiences from incident response, including lessons learned and successful defense strategies• Exchange information on vulnerabilities, particularly those being actively exploited or that are especially critical for your sector🛠️ Standards and Tools:• Use standardized formats such as STIX (Structured Threat Information eXpression) for the structured exchange of threat information• Implement automated exchange protocols such as TAXII (Trusted Automated eXchange of Intelligence Information) for efficient, machine-readable exchange• Deploy Threat Intelligence Platforms (TIPs) that automate the import, analysis, enrichment, and export of threat intelligence• Use APIs for the direct integration of external threat feeds into your security systems such as SIEM, firewalls, or EDR solutions• Implement tools for the automatic normalization and deduplication of threat intelligence from various sources🔄 Operationalization of Shared Intelligence:• Develop clear processes for the assessment, prioritization, and integration of externally sourced threat intelligence into your security systems• Implement feedback loops to assess the quality and relevance of externally sourced intelligence and adjust your sharing strategy accordingly• Create dedicated roles or teams responsible for the analysis and operationalization of shared threat intelligence• Develop metrics to measure the value and effectiveness of threat intelligence sharing, such as the number of threats detected or incidents prevented• Integrate external threat intelligence into your incident response processes for more context-rich and informed decisions during security incidents

Question 20

How can organizations integrate a comprehensive vulnerability management strategy into their threat analysis?

Accepted Answer

An effective vulnerability management strategy is a critical component of comprehensive threat analysis. Integrating both areas enables context-based prioritization of vulnerabilities based on actual threats and business risks.🔍 Comprehensive Vulnerability Detection:• Implement a multi-layered approach to vulnerability detection that combines various techniques such as regular automated scans, manual penetration tests, code reviews, and bug bounty programs• Extend the scope of your vulnerability assessments beyond traditional IT systems to cloud environments, containers, IoT devices, OT systems, and mobile applications• Integrate vulnerability detection into the entire software development lifecycle by implementing DevSecOps practices and automated security tests in CI/CD pipelines• Conduct regular configuration audits to identify configuration errors and deviations from security baselines, which are often just as critical as software vulnerabilities• Implement continuous monitoring to detect new vulnerabilities promptly as they become known or as new assets are added📊 Threat Intelligence-Based Prioritization:• Integrate current threat intelligence into your vulnerability management process to prioritize vulnerabilities that are actively being exploited by attackers• Use frameworks such as EPSS (Exploit Prediction Scoring System) to assess the likelihood of vulnerability exploitation more precisely than traditional CVSS scores alone• Develop a multi-factor prioritization model that considers factors such as exploit availability, threat actor interest, business criticality, and exposure• Implement attack path mapping to identify vulnerabilities that are part of potential attack paths to critical assets and therefore require particular attention• Consider industry-specific threats and attack trends particularly relevant to your organization when prioritizing🛠️ Effective Remediation Strategies:• Develop clear, SLA-based remediation timelines based on the risk assessment of each vulnerability, with shorter deadlines for more critical vulnerabilities• Implement a risk-based patch management process that balances the urgency of patches with operational requirements and change management processes• Use virtual patching through WAFs, IPS, or RASP solutions as a temporary measure for vulnerabilities that cannot be remediated immediately• Use automation for the deployment and validation of patches to increase efficiency and reduce human error• Establish a structured exception management process for cases where vulnerabilities cannot be remediated within standard timelines for technical or operational reasons📈 Continuous Improvement and Metrics:• Develop meaningful metrics for your vulnerability management program, such as average time-to-remediate, patch coverage rate, or risk exposure score• Conduct regular maturity analyses of your vulnerability management program and compare your performance against industry standards and best practices• Implement a continuous improvement process based on retrospective analyses and lessons learned from the remediation of previous vulnerabilities• Conduct regular stakeholder reviews to communicate the value and effectiveness of your vulnerability management program and ensure continued support• Use advanced analytics and trend evaluations to identify systemic issues or recurring vulnerability patterns that may indicate more fundamental security problems

Threat Analysis

Your strategic success starts here

For optimal preparation of your strategy session:

Certifications, Partners and more...

Threat Analysis

Our Strengths

Expert Tip

ADVISORI in Numbers

11+

120+

520+

Our Approach:

Sarah Richter

Our Services

Threat Intelligence & Analysis

Risk Assessment & Prioritization

Protection Strategies & Implementation

Our Areas of Expertise in Information Security

Frequently Asked Questions about Threat Analysis

How can an organization implement an effective threat analysis and benefit from it?

🔍 Methodical Approach:

🌐 Threat Intelligence Integration:

📊 Risk Assessment and Prioritization:

🛡 ️ Integration into Security Operations:

Which modern technologies and methods are advancing threat analysis?

🤖 Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning:

🔄 Automation and Orchestration:

📊 Visualization and Contextualization:

🌐 Collaborative Approaches:

How can organizations link their threat analysis to their overall security strategy?

🔄 Strategic Alignment:

🛠 ️ Operational Integration:

📊 Governance and Compliance:

🔄 Incident Response and Business Continuity:

How can organizations continuously improve their threat analysis capabilities?

📊 Maturity Models and Assessments:

👥 Team and Competency Development:

🔍 Process Optimization:

🔄 Feedback Loops and Integration:

What role does threat intelligence play in threat analysis and how can it be used effectively?

📊 Types and Sources of Threat Intelligence:

🔍 Intelligence Processing and Analysis:

🌐 Operationalization of Threat Intelligence:

📱 People and Process:

How can organizations use threat analyses to develop targeted prevention strategies?

🛡 ️ Strategic Planning:

🔒 Technical Implementation:

📊 Monitoring and Validation:

👥 Organizational Measures:

What role do Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) play in the modern threat landscape?

🔍 Characteristics and Evolution:

👤 Actors and Motivations:

🔄 Attack Methodology and Tactics:

🛡 ️ Defense Strategies:

How can organizations effectively integrate threat hunting into their threat analysis?

🎯 Strategic Foundations:

🔍 Methodical Approach:

⚙ ️ Technological Enablers:

👥 Team and Capabilities:

How can an organization systematically analyze and reduce its attack surface?

🔍 Attack Surface Mapping and Inventory:

🛡 ️ Fundamental Reduction Strategies:

🔄 Advanced Methods:

📊 Continuous Monitoring and Management:

How can threat analysis be integrated into DevSecOps processes?

🔄 Shift-Left Approach:

🛠 ️ Pipeline Integration:

🔍 Continuous Threat Analysis:

👥 Culture and Processes:

How do threat analyses differ for on-premises, cloud, and hybrid environments?

🏢 On-Premises Environments:

☁ ️ Cloud Environments:

🔄 Hybrid Environments:

🛠 ️ Methodological Differences:

What role do cyber threat frameworks play in threat analysis?

📋 MITRE ATT&CK Framework:

🔄 Cyber Kill Chain:

🛡 ️ NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF):

📊 Diamond Model of Intrusion Analysis:

How can organizations integrate IoT- and OT-specific threats into their threat analysis?